Enru Logo

Why Catalogs Still Matter in a Digital World

feature book picture

In an age where digital marketing strategies dominate the landscape, it might surprise you to learn that catalogs are still king. 72% of Americans still enjoy browsing through catalogs. Even better, 84% of those people turn that moment of joy into action: sharing it with someone else, making a purchase, or visiting a store or website. Catalogs bring the greatest return on your marketing investment!

These statistics not only highlight the enduring appeal of catalogs but also underscore their unique ability to engage consumers in ways that digital ads often cannot. Despite all the very real benefits of digital marketing, catalogs remain a powerful tool in the marketing mix. Let’s take this opportunity to explore just how effective catalog marketing is, how you can maintain its effectiveness, and the fundamental reasons for its success.

Key Stats:

  • 72% of Americans enjoy browsing through catalogs.
  • 84% of catalog recipients either share the catalog, make a purchase, or visit a store or website.

Catalog Marketing’s High ROI and Cost Effectiveness

Catalogs continue to demonstrate a high return on investment (ROI) that often surpasses digital channels. Studies have found that catalogs achieve a median ROI of 29%, outperforming both online display ads and paid digital search, which both have a median ROI of 23%​​​​. Marketers are always looking for the best way to reach customers, and the catalog is the undefeated champ.

However, this historical trend is under threat. The July 2024 USPS rate increases pose a challenge for catalogers, since postage costs are a major part of direct mail expenses. Marketing Mail rates, for example, are expected to increase by an average of 7.55%. These increases could strain marketing budgets and lead some businesses to reconsider their catalog marketing strategies.

But Enru’s co-mail services offer a solution to mitigate these rising costs. By leveraging Enru’s proprietary High-Density Co-Mail program, catalogers can significantly reduce postage costs, saving even more than before the postal increase. For example, Enru’s High-Density Co-Mail can reduce postage rates for Marketing Mail by 19% through a combination of industry-leading co-mail capabilities, proprietary technology, and relationship with the USPS. These savings make catalog marketing more affordable, even in the face of rising postal rates.

Enru’s co-mail services not only reduce costs – they enhance the efficiency and predictability of mail delivery. By consolidating mailings, Enru minimizes the number of touchpoints and streamlines the logistics process, ensuring timely delivery of catalogs. That helps maintain the high ROI of catalog marketing because catalogs reach consumers in a timely manner, maximizing their impact and engagement potential.

Key Stats:

  • Direct mail achieves a median ROI of 29%.
  • July 2024 USPS rate increases will drive up postage rates 7-10%.
  • Enru’s High-Density Co-Mail program can reduce marketing mail rates by 19%.

The Tangibility Advantage of Catalogs

Just how is it that catalogs have retained their marketing power through all the changes in our world? One of the most compelling advantages of catalog marketing is its tangibility. In a world saturated with digital ads that often go unnoticed or are quickly forgotten, catalogs offer a tactile experience that creates a lasting impression. When a consumer holds a catalog in their hands, it engages multiple senses, making the interaction more memorable and impactful. This physical presence is something digital ads simply cannot replicate.

A 2021 study by the United States Postal Service found that 87% of consumers reported that catalogs make them more interested in a retailer’s products. This heightened interest is further supported by the fact that consumers spend an average of 15.5 minutes browsing a catalog, exponentially longer than they would on a typical digital ad​​. Additionally, catalogs have a retention rate that digital ads can’t match, with 55% of recipients keeping catalogs for at least a month, providing repeated exposure to the brand and its products​​.

This prolonged engagement is crucial for building brand loyalty and recognition. According to a recent survey, 65% of consumers are more likely to remember a brand after receiving a catalog, compared to just 10-20% recall for digital ads​​. This higher recall rate translates into stronger brand associations and greater customer loyalty over time.

Moreover, the tangible nature of catalogs conveys a sense of value and trustworthiness. A significant 57% of consumers feel more valued when they receive mail from brands they trust​​. This emotional connection fosters a deeper relationship between the consumer and the brand, which is essential for long-term customer retention.

In an era where noise is overwhelming, the tangibility of catalogs stands out. They create a more memorable, engaging, and valued experience for consumers, making them an essential component of a successful marketing strategy.

Key Stats:

  • 87% of consumers say catalogs make them more interested in a retailer’s products.
  • Consumers spend an average of 15.5 minutes browsing a catalog.
  • 55% of recipients keep catalogs at least a month.
  • 65% of consumers are more likely to remember a brand after receiving a catalog.
  • 57% of consumers say they feel more valued when they receive mail from trusted brands.

Catalog Marketing’s Targeted Reach and Personalization

Another standout benefit of catalog marketing is the ability to precisely target the right audience. Where broad campaigns may struggle with ad fatigue and low engagement rates, catalogs can be tailored to specific demographics, purchase histories, and interests, ensuring that marketing efforts reach the most receptive audience.

A 2019 case study by J.Crew highlights the effectiveness of targeted catalog campaigns. Customers who received catalogs spent 2.5 times more money than those who only received digital promotions​​. This substantial increase in spending underscores the value of reaching the right audience with personalized content.

The ability to target specific segments allows for more meaningful interactions with potential customers. By tailoring the content to the recipients’ preferences and behaviors, catalogs can deliver a more personalized experience that resonates on a deeper level. This personalized approach not only enhances the consumer experience – it increases the likelihood of conversion.

Key Stats:

  • Customers who received catalogs spend 2.5 times more money than those receiving digital promotions.
  • 57% of consumers find print marketing more trustworthy than other media.
  • Personalized direct mail generates 36% higher response than non-personalized.

Multichannel Integration Through Catalogs

In today’s interconnected marketing landscape, the ability to seamlessly integrate offline and online channels is crucial for maximizing reach and impact. Catalogs play a pivotal role in bridging the gap between these channels, sending traffic to digital platforms and boosting overall sales. By leveraging the strengths of both print and digital marketing, businesses can create a cohesive marketing strategy that drives consumer engagement and conversion.

Catalogs have been shown to effectively drive online traffic and sales. According to a study by Harvard Business Review, 20% of catalog recipients made a purchase within 90 days of receiving the catalog. More interestingly, 49% of those purchases occurred online! This demonstrates how catalogs can serve as a powerful catalyst to get consumers to visit websites, explore products, and make purchases.

As we’ve already discussed, the tactile nature of catalogs engages consumers in a way that other ads often fail to do, creating a more memorable and impactful experience. This enhanced engagement can motivate recipients to check out the brand online. For instance, one-third of catalog recipients immediately visited a retail website!

Catalogs can serve as a bridge between offline and online marketing efforts by incorporating digital elements such as QR codes, personalized URLs, and social media handles. These elements provide a direct link between the physical catalog and the digital world, making it easy for readers to transition from browsing a catalog to exploring more online.

Key Stats:

  • 20% of catalog recipients make a purchase within 90 days of receipt.
  • 49% of catalog purchases occur online.
  • 33% of catalog recipients immediately visit a retail website.

Maximizing the Power of Catalogs in a Digital Age

In an increasingly digital world, catalogs remain a powerful and indispensable tool in the marketing mix. Their unique ability to create a tangible, memorable experience sets them apart from fleeting digital ads, making them an essential component for driving consumer engagement and loyalty.

As postal rates increase, it is more important than ever for catalogers to find creative ways to maintain the effectiveness and affordability of their campaigns. Enru’s postal optimization services, particularly the High-Density Co-Mail program, provide the tools you need to navigate these challenges. By maximizing the benefits of catalog marketing, businesses can continue to achieve strong engagement, high ROI, and lasting customer loyalty in the digital age.
Embrace the enduring power of catalogs with Enru’s expert solutions and keep your marketing strategy both effective and cost-efficient, ensuring that your brand remains memorable and impactful amid the digital noise.